It was only last August when I assured everyone that the Giants would finish ahead of the Athletics, but it would probably be close. That didn’t wind up being the case, as the Giants got to 81 wins compared to teh A’s 76, but there’s something interesting about going back and reading through some of the comments. The vibes tend to bounce between a flippant attitude about any sort of comparison between the two teams and outright churlishness. Are the Athletics a major league team? Not exactly. But that’s why the Giants losing to them is worthy of a story, should it happen.
I think the Giants would find it embarrassing to finish the season behind the franchise they helped kill. The A’s are set to be in the region for one more calendar year, unless there’s a lockout that cancels the 2027 season. That’d be quite a note to go out on. Bragging rights and spite are potent weapons when deployed properly.
But so are talented baseball players, and the nomadic Athletics have a fair amount on their roster. They enter this series sitting atop the AL West at 22-21 thanks to a slightly above average lineup (102 wRC+) buoying a below average pitching staff (23rd in fWAR) and, of course, some general non-competitiveness from the rest of their division. On paper, the Giants can’t really compete with the Athletics’ lineup and it’s only the pitching where San Francisco would seem to have the advantage. But Sutter Health Field is close to Coors Field in terms of park factor which should mean that a more talented lineup has the advantage if the pitching is about equal.
Then again, the Giants have a pretty relevant equalizer there, too, in that Sutter Health Field is also the home of their Triple-A squadron. It was Bryce Eldridge’s home for a time. Trevor McDonald’s. Heliot Ramos and Casey Schmitt’s, too. That’s not nothing, and that will be a fun thing to watch, provided Eldridge actually gets into a game. The Athletics haven’t been all that great there in the season-plus they’ve used it as a homefield. This year, they’re off to a 9-10 start with a -20 run differential.
But the preview here is that the Athletics feature patience (9.7 BB%) and power (.153 ISO) the Giants lack and have used that combination to overcome an even worse start to the season (1-5) than the one the Giants had (2-4).
Series overview
Who: San Francisco Giants (18-26) at The Athletics (22-21)
Where: Sutter Health Field | West Sacramento, California
When: Friday at 6:40pm PT, Saturday at 6:40pm PT, Sunday at 1:05pm PT
National broadcasts: None, but all 3 listed as the MLB.tv Free Game of the Day
Projected starters
Friday: TBD vs. Aaron Civale (RHP 4-1, 2.59 ERA)
Saturday: Trevor McDonald (RHP 1-0, 2.92 ERA) vs. Luis Severino (RHP 2-4, 4.07 ERA)
Sunday: Adrian Houser (RHP 1-4, 5.79 ERA) vs. Jeffrey Springs (LHP 3-3, 4.22 ERA)
Players to watch
Athletics
Nick Kurtz: The 2025 AL Rookie of the Year posted a 1.o02 OPS with 36 home runs in his age-22 season (489 PA). He’s up to a .905 OPS in 193 PA through the first month and a half of the season. 6 of his 7 home runs have come over the past 23 games.
Shea Langeliers: He currently leads the sport in hits with 55 hits along with 12 home runs. He’s a bit off of Cal Raleigh’s 60-home run pace from last season (he had 14 through his team’s first 43 games), but it’s worth keeping an eye on.
Joel Kuhnel & Hogan Harris: You’d think trading Mason Miller would leave the backend of the Athletics’ pen compeltely exposed. That hasn’t totally been the case, and they’ve at least populated it with some quirky characters. First up is soft-tossing journeyman righty Joel Kuhnel, who is doing it with a sinker that simply gets the job done. He has just 6 strikeouts in 15 innings. He got a nice writeup in MLB.com last month. Meanwhile, lefty reliever Hogan Harris is approaching journeyman status (29, despite being drafted by the A’s) and has walked 17 in 23 IP — but has also struck out 21.
Giants
Bryce Eldridge: We can’t consider 104 games spread out across a few years an indication of a home field, but this is where he was getting comfortable before the Giants called him up to sit on the bench. Let’s see if he gets a start or really any playing time in what was his minor league home for a time.
Trevor McDonald: Unlike Eldridge, McDonald will be returning to a place where he did not impress, sporting a 5.40 ERA the past two seasons. As a starter on the mound for the San Francisco Giants, he has been a tough starting pitcher. Will he hold firm to that characterization or lose himself in the West Sacramento of it all?
Daniel Susac: He’s set to be activated for this series and we’ll see if the organization’s favorite catcher can pickup where he left off.
Tony Vitello watch
Like some of the recent River Cats now with the Giants, I imagine there’s a degree of familiarity for Vitello in that Sutter Health Field should feel a lot more like a college stadium than a major league one. But maybe I’m wrong about that!
Prediction time
The Giants will not get swept.
